Spice Girls – Wannabe
When I was around seven or eight years old, my favorite band was, of course, the Spice Girls. I listened to their music on repeat and even learned every single word to their songs. I didn’t know I could possibly appreciate their music even more than I did then, but I certainly did after I went to my first Spice Girls concert. Even they sounded a lot “better” (in terms of pitch and harmony) on the CDs I had back home, to me, being at the venue and listening to the real Spice Girls singing in front of me was so much more meaningful than just to the same CD over and over again.
In hindsight, I think I really appreciated the fact that they improvised their solos and talked between their singing – it reminded me that the Spice Girls weren’t just about British pop, but they were also about girls celebrating girls and musical freedom. Most importantly, it didn’t matter to me that they didn’t have perfect singing; their flat notes and improvisation made me see that they were real people, not just 5 plastic girls in platform heels.
Spice Girls -Wannabe Live in Paris
The same thing can be said for musicians playing in all forms of genres. Whether it is R&B, hip-hop, rock, or jazz, musical improvisation is the artist’s ability to give new life and animation a piece; renewing our curiosity and interest as listeners. To me, only live music can bring us this unpredictability – music records can only try to replicate real, spontaneous artistic expression.
Sally Kwok

It really speaks to me that the person feels this way about their favorite artist, and that she didn’t care much about their quality of music live, but rather about the performance itself. I have been to several concerts by my favorite bands, and the best experiences that I’ve had were not the bands who played most like the recordings on their CDs, or those who played most in tune with a high quality of music caliber, but rather those who engaged the audiences, had fun with what they were performing, and how they created new things with their music.
Death Cab for Cutie, for example – amazing band, a variety of skills and talent there, but they were not as fantastic live as I had expected them to be. Maybe there is an inverse relationship when it comes to pure musical genius/talent and stage presence. I wouldn’t say that the Spice Girls, Blink 182, or N’Sync has amazing musical talent, but they all do have terrific ways of expressing their music to a live audience; they are, for lack of a better phrase, amazing entertainers.